Back to site
Fatemeh Zamaninia
Ph.D. Counseling Student, Counseling Group, Mashhad Unit, Islamic Azad University, Mashhad, Iran. f.zaman21@yahoo.com
Mohammadjavad Asghari Ibrahimabad Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran (Corresponding Author). mjasghari@um.ac.ir
Ali Akbar Thamari Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Kashmar Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashmar, Iran. Aasamari87@gmail.com
Received: 1402/11/09 Revised: 1403/03/11 Accepted: 1403/03/25 Published: 1403/03/30
Cite as: Zamaninia, Fatemeh; Asghari Ibrahimabad, Mohammadjavad; Thamari, Ali Akbar. (1403). Comparison of the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women. Journal of Clinical Psychology Research and Counseling, 14(1). doi: 10.22067/tpccp.2024.86170.1613 Abstract Objective: The present study aimed to compare the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women.
Method: The research method was a quasi-experimental design with two experimental groups, a pre-test—post-test design, and one control group. The statistical population included all married women experiencing infertility who had referred to the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad in the winter of 1400. Forty-five participants were selected using convenience sampling and then randomly assigned to three groups of 15 (two experimental groups and one control group). The instruments used were the Loneliness Questionnaire and the Emotional Divorce Questionnaire. Participants responded to the pre-test. Then, the experimental groups received emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy over eight 90-minute sessions. The control group received no intervention. After completing the sessions, the post-test was administered. Data were analyzed using SPSS-26 and repeated-measures analysis of variance.
Results: The findings showed that in the post-test and follow-up stages, there was a significant difference between the experimental groups (emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy) and the control group (P < 0/001). The results also indicated that schema therapy was more effective than emotion-focused therapy in reducing feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in women.
Keywords: feelings of loneliness, emotional divorce, emotion-focused therapy, schema therapy, infertile women Introduction Infertility is a common problem worldwide, and up to 20% of couples are affected (Nguyen, 2014; Sadock & Sodock, 2007). According to reports from the World Health Organization, more than 80 million couples (about 10%) in the world are infertile. Meanwhile, based on different results, more than 3 million Iranian couples (13 to 15%) are infertile. The average lifetime prevalence of infertility in Iran is 10.9%, meaning 3.3% of the population experience common infertility. In the Middle East, infertility incidence is estimated at 10% to 15% (Nasr Esfahani et al., 2022).
According to the social role theory, a set of interdependent “rule-based and shaped expectations” is described as being resistant and stable, which provides the holder of particular social positions with value. In other words, the individual is directed toward a specific social position based on the expected role. Example: It is expected that a physician, according to the latest and most up-to-date level of medical research, will do everything possible to treat patients; or it is expected that a married woman will give birth to a child (or children) and will devote all efforts to raising them. In such cases, if the woman is infertile and does not meet the expectations that others in society have of her, she is essentially not fulfilling her social role properly (Afshari et al., 2019).
The social view of infertility states that common values and norms in society have a significant impact on the experience of infertility and on couples. In most cultures, having a child is considered a social value. Explicit and implicit norms indicate that couples want and should have children; therefore, when couples cannot have children, existing norms are disrupted and they may face social stigma. Family members and peers may hold negative views of the couple. Infertile people may offer difficult experiences when facing children and pregnant women; therefore, they may distance themselves from friends, experience social isolation, and may not participate in family gatherings in order to avoid feelings of failure (Loftus & Namaste, 2011; Rajabi et al., 2018).
Social isolation of women—limited interaction with friends, acquaintances, or neighbors—lack of access to support systems, and the presence of imposed psychological pressures, exposes them to greater strain in marital life and lowers their satisfaction with married life. In fact, the feeling of loneliness, especially if accompanied by adverse experiences of childhood abuse, leads to a reduction in perceived emotional and social support among women (Saeidi et al., 2020).
Feelings of loneliness are considered a psychological construct independent of other problems and can also involve other harms (Cava et al., 2021). Loneliness is not merely an objective lack of external companionship; rather, it refers to inner loneliness (Sandra et al., 2022).
An overall assessment of the marital relationship and the extent to which personal and couples’ needs, desires, and wishes are met determines the level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the marital relationship. One of the most important social harms is divorce. On the other hand, the roots of many social harms must, in some way, be considered in close relationship with the incorrect functioning of the family institution (Khan Mohamammadi et al., 2018). Often, after some time, a woman, a man, or both begin to doubt the depth and form of their relationship and fail to align their expectations about life with the realities of their marital life. As a result, they become cold and lose enthusiasm in their lives. Additionally, couples find that their spouse’s behavior is not what they expected. After this sense of disappointment emerges, they compare their spouse before and after marriage, and negative feelings overcome them, leading to the loss of initial enthusiasm, diminished emotional attachment, and ultimately the emergence of emotional divorce (Rezvani & Saemi, 2019). Specifically, infertility exacerbates emotional needs, affects one’s perception of the situation, creates negative emotions, intensifies a cold relationship, and leads to emotional divorce.
The experience of infertility goes beyond a physiological deficiency. Infertility also has psychological and social dimensions, causing both sexes to face a wide range of psychological harms, including reduced quality of life, lowered self-esteem, sexual dysfunction, marital problems, increased tension, feelings of loneliness, depression, emotional divorce, and feelings of inadequacy, along with many other issues. Infertility causes disturbances in sexual and emotional relationships, fear of separation, feelings of loneliness, and depression in infertile individuals; however, these problems affect women in society more. Infertility is a problem that is almost solvable in today’s world. Nevertheless, infertile women face psychological problems while waiting for this condition to be resolved (Nguyen, 2014).
Despite all medical advances, a significant proportion of infertile women and men remain among those who still have not succeeded in treating their infertility problem. Infertility is not only a medical condition; this issue and its treatment can affect various aspects of individuals’ lives and may bring along psychological and emotional problems such as depression, anxiety, hopelessness, feelings of guilt, and feelings of worthlessness (Afshari et al., 2019).
Regardless of which member of the couple is the main cause of infertility, due to social prejudice, infertility is considered a “female problem.” Therefore, women usually face more family and social issues than men and are exposed to more psychological harms. If early maladaptive schemas, as well as primary and secondary emotional processes and unmet emotional needs of infertile women are not resolved and do not lead to positive solutions, it can turn into tension in life. This is because early maladaptive schemas are self-harming emotional and cognitive patterns that form at the beginning of development and repeatedly occur throughout life (Young et al., 2006).
It is stated that emotion-focused therapy, using techniques from other approaches such as structured couple therapy approaches (attachment, adaptation, tracking the cycle, reappraisal), (client-centered) therapeutic alliance, self-disclosure, unconditional positive acceptance, empathy and mutual understanding (Gestalt therapy, problem-solving), strengthening relational strengths, highlighting individual capabilities and competencies, and also systemic approaches and attachment theory, helps improve couples’ relationships. Most of the time, purely logical and rational assessment (cognitive therapy) prevents the therapist from examining the emotional issues of the spouses. On the other hand, many couples’ problems originate from how they express underlying emotions. Emotion-focused therapy emphasizes identifying communication patterns, emotions, feelings, and the exchange of attachment styles. When individuals express their needs and desires to their spouse, they feel closer and more intimate, the relational turmoil decreases, and this leads to reduced feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce (Ahmadloo & Zeinali, 2018).
Additionally, the more individuals have greater numbers of early maladaptive schemas, the more these schemas cause bias in interpreting events, leading to misunderstanding, cognitive distortions, incorrect guesses and inferences, and unrealistic expectations in interpersonal psychological impairment. Schemas that lead to psychological problems can be described as being related to individuals’ intimate relationships and also to emotional divorce. The goal is to correct irrational ideas, inefficient beliefs, erroneous interpretations and cognitive errors; create a sense of control over life; facilitate constructive self-talk; and strengthen coping skills (Ussher & Perz, 2017).
Considering that research on psychological and family issues, including feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertility, is limited and a gap in research in this area is evident, and with the aim of examining psychological injuries in infertile women, the following hypotheses were pursued:
- There is a significant difference between the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness in infertile women.
- There is a significant difference between the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on emotional divorce in infertile women. Method, Statistical Population, and Sampling Method This research is an applied study conducted in a quasi-experimental design with a pre-test—post-test plan with a control group. First, pre-tests were administered to each of the three groups (two experimental and one control). The statistical population consisted of all infertile women who had referred to the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad in winter 1400, and the research sample was selected from among 45 women. Using convenience sampling, two experimental groups and one control group were randomly assigned. After attrition in the experimental groups, all groups were reduced to 12 participants each.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria: Inclusion criteria included having at least a high-school diploma, being married, diagnosis of primary and secondary infertility based on medical data, and not using psychotropic medications. Exclusion criteria included lack of willingness to cooperate and separation from the spouse during the period of conducting the sessions.
Before implementing the program, in order to apply maximum control, attempts were made so that the groups under study were, as far as possible, similar in terms of demographic characteristics (education, duration of marriage, and occupation). After the proposal was approved and the university council confirmed it by obtaining permission from the university and visiting the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad, experimental and control groups were selected. Interventions for the experimental groups were held as two 90-minute sessions per week. Based on the protocol for emotion-focused therapy derived from the article by Seyed Sharifi and colleagues (Seyed Sharifi et al., 2021) and related books, as well as the protocol for schema therapy by Young (Young et al., 2006), the sessions were implemented by the researcher in year (1400). It should be noted that the control group received no intervention.
To observe ethical considerations, all participants were assured that their personal information would remain confidential. It should also be noted that this research was derived from the Ph.D. thesis in Counseling at Islamic Azad University of Mashhad and has the ethics code IR.IAU.MSHD.REC.1401.158, approved by and reviewed at the Faculty of Medicine of Islamic Azad University—Mashhad Medical Sciences Unit. Research Instruments 1. Loneliness Questionnaire This scale was developed by Russell and colleagues (Russell et al., 1980) in 1980. It includes 20 items, rated on a 4-point scale: 10 negatively worded sentences and 10 positively worded sentences. Scoring and interpretation in this questionnaire include: never (1), rarely (2), sometimes (3), and always (4). However, items 1, 5, 6, 9, 10, 15, 16, 19, and 20 are reverse-scored. That means they are coded as: never (4), rarely (3), sometimes (2), and always (1). The score range is between 20 (minimum) and 80 (maximum).
Therefore, the mean score is 50. Scores higher than the mean indicate greater intensity of loneliness. Validity and Reliability: Reliability of this test in its new revised version was reported as 78%. Test reliability using the test-retest method was reported by Russell and colleagues (Russell et al., 1980) as 89%.
This scale was translated by Shakarkan and Miredrikvand and was then used after preliminary administration and revisions (Naderi & Haqshenas, 2009). The validity of the questionnaire was assessed and approved as “good” using the opinions of supervising and consulting professors. 2. Gottman’s Emotional Divorce Questionnaire This scale, provided by John Gottman in the book Success or Failure in Marriage, consists of 24 items scored as yes (1) and no (0), measuring the level of emotional divorce (Gottman et al., 1998). Its validity and reliability have been applied based on the research by Rajai (Kimiaei et al., 2015). Further Findings Table 8 shows that the within-group repetition factor (F = 109/391, P = 0/001), the group-by-repetition interaction factor (F = 24/110, P = 0/001), and also the between-group factor (F = 70/990, P = 0/001) have a significant effect on emotional divorce in infertile women. The Bonferroni post hoc test showed that in the pre-test stage, there were no significant differences between the study groups (emotion-focused therapy, schema therapy, and control) in the variable of emotional divorce. However, in the post-test and follow-up stages, significant differences were observed between the emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy groups compared with the control group (P = 0/001).
Table 9: Results of repeated-measures ANOVA of the effect of schema therapy and emotion-focused therapy on the emotional divorce variable in infertile women Source of variation | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F value | Sig. | Effect Size Pre-test factor | 8/665 | 1 | 8/665 | 0/700 | 0/412 | 0/032 Group membership factor | 1270/515 | 1 | 1270/515 | 102/651 | 0/0001 | 0/63 Pre-test factor | 69/409 | 1 | 69/409 | 8/353 | 0/009 | 0/29 Group membership factor | 984/549 | 1 | 984/549 | 118/479 | 0/0001 | 0/55 In the comparison between emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy, the results showed that clinically, the effectiveness and effect size of schema therapy (Eta = %63) for the variable of emotional divorce is better and greater than that of emotion-focused therapy (Eta = %55). Discussion and Conclusion The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women, and the findings showed that the study is consistent with the results of Suleimanabadi and Suleimanabadi (Suleimanabadi, 2021). Infertility, as a factor, causes both sexes to experience a broad range of psychological harms including reduced quality of life, decreased self-esteem, sexual dysfunction and marital problems, increased tension, feelings of loneliness, depression, emotional divorce, and feelings of inefficacy.
Both emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy are effective in reducing feelings of loneliness in infertile women.
This finding is consistent with the results of Fatemi Asl and colleagues (Fatemi Asl et al., 2019). It is also consistent with Ghafari Shahir and colleagues (Ghafari Shahir et al., 2021) and PourMohamad G. and colleagues (PourMohamad G. et al., 2019). Nikoogoftar and Sangani (Nikoogoftar & Sangani, 2020) found in their study that group schema therapy is effective in reducing rumination, feelings of loneliness, and increasing general health among divorced women. Moradi et al. (2020) found that emotion-focused training reduces emotional divorce and coldness in women. The results of Esmaili et al. (2023) showed that schema therapy is effective in distress tolerance, emotional divorce, and marital intimacy in couples, which is consistent with the present study. This is also aligned with the studies by Enez (Enez, 2021), Greenman and Johnson (Greenman & Johnson, 2022), Thompson and Girz (Thompson & Girz, 2020), Sandra and colleagues (Sandra et al., 2022), and Bishop and colleagues (Bishop et al., 2022).
Reviewing the results showed that emotion-focused therapy can be effective in improving feelings of loneliness in infertile women. Regarding the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy on loneliness in infertile couples, it is important to note that one of the primary goals of emotion-focused therapy is to change insecure attachment styles into secure attachment. Emotional contact emerges through availability and responsiveness. This bond and secure attachment meet the individual’s inner needs for safety, support, and connection. In secure marital relationships, if each person is confident that their spouse is available, that they have appropriate emotional support for one another, and that they value each other’s emotional needs, they experience less loneliness in their relationship (Bach et al., 2018).
In other words, a large part of the relationship among couples in Iranian society stems from emotional and psychological issues. Inability to express these emotions in a timely and appropriate manner initially leads to emotional withdrawal, the loss of intimacy, feelings of loneliness, and ultimately emotional divorce. In emotion-focused therapy, attention is given to identifying communication patterns, emotions, feelings, and the exchange of attachment styles among individuals. Communication and interaction patterns of spouses determine the level of trust and intimacy between couples, and destructive interaction style increases emotional distance, which in turn intensifies conflicting and negative emotions toward each other. Infertile women, who have unexpressed or suppressed emotions, do not receive the necessary and sufficient emotional support from their spouses and feel abandoned by their spouses. This results in distancing between the couple and feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce. Therefore, feelings of loneliness in infertile women are accompanied by all the psychological problems mentioned above, and using psychology approaches helps them improve considerably (Hoseinzade et al., 2021).
Regarding the effectiveness of the study results, schema therapy is more effective in improving feelings of loneliness and reducing emotional divorce. Considering that early schemas include people’s thoughts and beliefs about themselves, others, and the environment, created as a result of unmet early needs—especially emotional needs (Bach et al., 2018). Schemas and cognitive beliefs influence the course of marital relationships, and this issue has long been considered. When one or both spouses have high levels of irrational beliefs and inflexible thoughts, marital satisfaction gradually decreases (Hoseinzade et al., 2021).
Schema therapy helps infertile women talk about what is happening in their inner world as well as what they experience, including physical feelings, thoughts, beliefs, and values. When individuals gain insight into the origins of their maladaptive patterns, their life and relationship take on new meaning; they leave negative interactions and inappropriate personality patterns behind and move toward a healthier mindset. It also provides a way to escape life traps and meet their basic emotional needs. Schema therapy techniques help individuals, through emotional reorganization, examining new learning, interpersonal emotional regulation, and self-soothing, to create the conditions for improving schemas. These schemas generally operate at the deepest cognitive level, often outside conscious awareness. Schema therapy improves avoidant personality disorders, loneliness, and distancing behaviors (Titov et al., 2015).
With its multidimensional perspective and by considering the impact of cognitions and attitudes, schema therapy examines the roots of the problem in the past and seeks awareness and insight in women (Sedaghat & Afraee, 2022). The presence of maladaptive schemas is one of the main factors underlying the disruption of marital life. Some unfavorable and stressful environmental situations, such as infertility, activate maladaptive schemas that form within the individual and create the context for various forms of psychological distress, such as depression, feelings of loneliness, inefficacy, substance abuse, interpersonal conflicts, and personality disorders. Infertility reduces women’s social status and is accompanied by the activation of early maladaptive schemas and emotional disturbances; ultimately, it prepares the ground for forming a vicious cycle that intensifies infertility (Jahangiri et al., 2017). Also, maladaptive schemas have been identified as ineffective cognitive strategies that lead to dissatisfaction in marital relationships and create conditions for separation (AkgÜL GÖK et al., 2019; Mahmoudpour et al., 2020).
In both therapies, individuals learn to regulate their emotions and improve their relationship with themselves and their spouse by identifying and meeting their basic needs and by playing their determining roles. Schema therapy also helps women use healthier coping strategies for internal triggers. If the therapist presents mindsets to participants in a personalized manner, they will understand them better. The abandoned child is part of the person’s existence that, based on the theoretical assumptions of schema therapy, has been subjected to abuse, abandonment, emotional neglect, domination, and severe, cruel criticism by the early family.
In the present study, both emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy were effective in feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women. The results showed that schema therapy worked better in reducing feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce. As a result, in addition to medical help for infertile women, schema therapy can be used to help infertile individuals. Regarding limitations, this study was conducted on infertile women; therefore, generalization to infertile couples or infertile men is not possible. It is suggested that the intervention be implemented with couples; and given the type of correlational research, it is also feasible with correlational designs.
At the end, the researchers would like to express their utmost gratitude and appreciation to all participants. In addition, there is no conflict of interest among the authors. References Afshari, P., Pejhan, A., & Rahmani Khalili, E. (2019). Factors and social consequences of infertility in shia and sunni women. Iran's Social Development Studies, 12(3), 103-115. https://jisds.srbiau.ac.ir/issue_2419_2470.html (In Persian)
Ahmadloo, M., & Zeinali, A. (2018). Predicting of emotional divorce based on novelty seeking, negative perfectionism and insecure attachment among employed women of urmia city. Iran Occupational Health, 15(2), 64-72. https://magiran.com/p1878272 (In Persian)
AkgÜL GÖK, F., Kapısız, S., Yilmaz, N., ÖZcan, S., & Duyan, V. (2019). Marital satisfaction and influencingfactors in infertile couples [İnfertil çiftlerde evlilik doyumu ve evlilik doyumunu etkileyen faktörler]. Cukurova Medical Journal, 44(3), 1074-1084. https://doi.org/10.17826/cumj.482385
Bach, B., Lockwood, G., & Young, J. E. (2018). A new look at the schema therapy model: Organization and role of early maladaptive schemas. Cognitive behaviour therapy, 47(4), 328-349. https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2017.1410566
Bishop, A., Younan, R., Low, J., & Pilkington, P. D. (2022). Early maladaptive schemas and depression in adulthood: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 29(1), 111-130. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2630
Cava, M.-J., Buelga, S., & Tomás, I. (2021). Peer victimization and dating violence victimization: The mediating role of loneliness, depressed mood, and life satisfaction. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 36(5-6), 2677-2702. https://doi.org/10.1177/0886260518760013
Enez, Ö. (2021). An overview of emotion-focused therapy. Current Research and Reviews in Psychology and Psychiatry, 1(1), 77-95. https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/crrpp/issue/68586/1075479
Esmaili, F., Zamordi, S., & Watankhah, H. (2023). The effectiveness of schema therapy on distress tolerance, emotional divorce and marital intimacy of couples. The tenth International Conference on Science and Technology of Educational Sciences, Social Studies and Psychology of Iran. https://civilica.com/doc/1966663.
Fatemi Asl, S., Goudarzi, M., Karimi Sani, P., & Boostanipour, A. (2019). The effect of emotionally-focused couple therapy (efct) on loneliness of hurt women from infidelity in salmas city. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology, 20(2), 48-57. https://doi.org/10.30486/jsrp.2019.665274 (In Persian)
Ghafari Shahir, M., Asadpour, E., & Zahrakar, K. (2021). Comparison effect of cognitive behavioral therapy and emotion-focused therapy on loneliness in married women victims of domestic violence [Research]. Advances in Cognitive Sciences, 23(1), 95-105. https://doi.org/10.30514/icss.23.1.95 (In Persian)
Gottman, J. M., Coan, J., Carrere, S., & Swanson, C. (1998). Predicting marital happiness and stability from newlywed interactions. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 5-22. https://doi.org/10.2307/353438
Greenman, P. S., & Johnson, S. M. (2022). Emotionally focused therapy: Attachment, connection, and health. Current Opinion in Psychology, 43, 146-150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2021.06.015
Hoseinzade, Z., Ghorbanshirodi, S., Khalatbari, J., & Rahmani, M. (2021). The comparison of the effectiveness of emotionally focused couples therapy and reality therapy for couples on marital communication beliefs and marital expectations of couples [Original Research]. Journal of Assessment and Research in Applied Counseling, 3(2), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.52547/jarcp.3.2.1 (In Persian)
Jahangiri, M. M., Teimouri, H., & Tahmasebian, H. (2017). Effectiveness of schema therapy on reducing anxiety and depression in infertile women of arak city [Research]. Journal of Medical Council of Islamic Republic of Iran, 35(3), 259-263. http://jmciri.ir/article-1-2785-fa.html (In Persian)
Khan Mohamammadi, Z., Bazzazian, S., Amiri Majd, M., & Ghamari, M. (2018). Predicting emotional divorce based on psychological basic needs, marital expectations and family function. Journal of Family Psychology, 5(1), 17-30. https://doi.org/10.22034/ijfp.2018.245536 (In Persian)
Kimiaei, A., Mashhadhi, A., & Rajaei, A. (2015). Investigating the effectiveness of Gutman method couple therapy on reducing emotional divorce, improving verbal-non-verbal relationships and interpersonal cognitive distortions of conflicted couples. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. Mashhad. https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir//#/articles/fd40e43d1b42ddc3d95556222dfc6402
Loftus, J., & Namaste, P. (2011). Expectant mothers: Women’s infertility and the potential identity of biological motherhood. Qualitative Sociology Review, 7, 36-54. https://doi.org/10.18778/1733-8077.07.1.02
Mahmoudpour, A., Darba, M., Kamandloo, Z., & Madani, Y. (2020). The relationship between early maladaptive schemas with marital satisfaction and psychological distress in infertile women in tehran [Research]. Journal of Psychological Science, 19(94), 1231-1242. http://psychologicalscience.ir/article-1-771-fa.html (In Persian)
Moradi, A., Tabrizi, M., Karami, A., & Balanchi, N. A. (2020). The effectiveness of emotion-based education on emotional divorce and cold-tempered women in isfahan with an islamic approach. https://sid.ir/paper/415123/en (In Persian)
Naderi, F., & Haqshenas, F. (2009). The relationship between impulsivity and loneliness with the amount of mobile phone use in students. Findings in Psychology (Social Psychology), 4(12), 111-121. https://sid.ir/paper/175115/fa (In Persian)
Nasr Esfahani, M., Kalantar, S. M., Montazri, F., Rajabi, M., & Daneshmand, F. (2022). Aneuploidy assessment of x, y, 18 chromosomes in sperm of oligoteratospermia using fish technique [Original article]. The Journal of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, 29(11), 4312-4321. https://doi.org/10.18502/ssu.v29i11.8507 (In Persian)
Nguyen, K. (2014). Why unexplained infertility is sometimes explained during ivf. Resolve for the Journey and Beyond.
Nikoogoftar, M., & Sangani, A. (2020). The effectiveness of schema therapy on rumination, loneliness and general health of divorced women. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology, 21(2), 1-12. https://www.sid.ir/paper/375104/fa (In Persian)
PourMohamad G., K., Zare, M. R., & Mandanizade Safi, S. (2019). The effectiveness of emotionally focused couple therapy (eft) on improving marital satisfaction and reduction tendency to extramarital relationships women affected by domestic violence [Research]. Rooyesh-e-Ravanshenasi Journal (RRJ), 8(8), 221-230. http://frooyesh.ir/article-1-1442-fa.html (In Persian)
Rajabi, G., Karimi, M., & Amanelahi, A. (2018). Marital satisfaction, and coping strategies in fertile and infertile women of ahvaz. Biannual Journal of Applied Counseling, 8(1), 45-62. https://doi.org/10.22055/jac.2018.24978.1570 (In Persian)
Rezvani, H., & Saemi, H. (2019). Correlation between self-differentiation and neuroticism with emotional divorce in married students of azad shahr azad university [Research]. Journal of Health Promotion Management, 8(2), 23-30. http://jhpm.ir/article-1-912-fa.html (In Persian)
Russell, D., Peplau, L. A., & Cutrona, C. E. (1980). The revised UCLA loneliness scale: Concurrent and discriminant validity evidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(3), 472-480. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.39.3.472
Sadock, B. J., & Sodock, V. A. (2007). Synopsis & Psychiatry Behavioral Sciences/Clinical Psychiatry (Tenth Edition ed.). Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Philadelphia. https://www.amazon.com/Kaplan-Sadocks-Synopsis-Psychiatry-Behavioral/dp/1609139712
Saeidi, M., Khalatbari, J., Ghorbanshiroudi, S., & Abolghasemi, S. (2020). Comparison of the effect of cognitive-behavioral therapy with compassion-focused therapy on impulsivity of women on the verge of divorce. Community Health Journal, 14(1), 73-83. https://doi.org/10.22123/chj.2020.187285.1296 (In Persian)
Sandra, L., Koesma, R. E., Soetikno, N., & Dewi, F. I. R. (2022). Emotion-focused coping as a mediator in the relationship between loneliness and self-injurious behavior in adolescents during the covid-19 pandemic. Journal of Positive Psychology and Wellbeing, 6(1), 2526-2537. https://mail.journalppw.com/index.php/jppw/article/view/3222
Sedaghat, M., & Afraee, R. (2022). The effectiveness of schema therapy on reducing emotional divorce in women with military spouses. Military Psychology, 13(49), 147-164. https://www.sid.ir/fileserver/jf/690-264537-fa-1071728.pdf (In Persian)
Seyed Sharifi, M., Navabinejad, P. D., S., & Farzad, P. D., V. (2021). A comparison of the effectiveness of emotionally focused and schema therapies in reducing externalizing problems of children in female-headed households [Research]. Quarterly Journal of Family and Research, 18(2), 73-88. http://qjfr.ir/article-1-1912-en.html (In Persian)
Suleimanabadi, S. S., F. (2021). Psychological injuries in infertile women. The Fifth Conference of New Findings in Obstetrics, Gynecology, Childbirth and Infertility in Georgia - Tbilisi (November-2021), International Academy of Sciences and Studies of Georgia. https://civilica.com/doc/1319094 (In Persian)
Thompson, S., & Girz, L. (2020). Overcoming shame and aloneness: Emotion-focused group therapy for self-criticism. Person-Centered & Experiential Psychotherapies, 19(1), 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1080/14779757.2019.1618370
Titov, N., Dear, B. F., Ali, S., Zou, J. B., Lorian, C. N., Johnston, L., Terides, M. D., Kayrouz, R., Klein, B., & Gandy, M. (2015). Clinical and cost-effectiveness of therapist-guided internet-delivered cognitive behavior therapy for older adults with symptoms of depression: A randomized controlled trial. Behavior Therapy, 46(2), 193-205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2014.09.008
Ussher, J., & Perz, J. (2017). Evaluation of the relative efficacy of a couple cognitive-behaviour therapy (cbt) for premenstrual disorders (pmds), in comparison to one-to-one cbt and a wait list control: A randomized controlled trial. 12(4). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0175068
Young, J. E., Klosko, J. S., & Weishaar, M. E. (2006). Schema therapy: A practitioner’s guide. https://www.guilford.com/books/Schema-Therapy/Young-Klosko-Weishaar/9781593853723
Learning article
Comparing the Effectiveness of Emotion-Focused Therapy and Schema Therapy on Feelings of Loneliness and Emotional Divorce in Infertile Women
Fatemeh Zamaninia Ph.D. Counseling Student, Counseling Group, Mashhad Unit, Islamic Azad University, Mashhad, Iran. f.zaman21@yahoo.com Mohammadjavad Asghari Ibrahimabad Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology,…
Mohammadjavad Asghari Ibrahimabad Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran (Corresponding Author). mjasghari@um.ac.ir
Ali Akbar Thamari Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Kashmar Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashmar, Iran. Aasamari87@gmail.com
Received: 1402/11/09 Revised: 1403/03/11 Accepted: 1403/03/25 Published: 1403/03/30
Cite as: Zamaninia, Fatemeh; Asghari Ibrahimabad, Mohammadjavad; Thamari, Ali Akbar. (1403). Comparison of the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women. Journal of Clinical Psychology Research and Counseling, 14(1). doi: 10.22067/tpccp.2024.86170.1613 Abstract Objective: The present study aimed to compare the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women.
Method: The research method was a quasi-experimental design with two experimental groups, a pre-test—post-test design, and one control group. The statistical population included all married women experiencing infertility who had referred to the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad in the winter of 1400. Forty-five participants were selected using convenience sampling and then randomly assigned to three groups of 15 (two experimental groups and one control group). The instruments used were the Loneliness Questionnaire and the Emotional Divorce Questionnaire. Participants responded to the pre-test. Then, the experimental groups received emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy over eight 90-minute sessions. The control group received no intervention. After completing the sessions, the post-test was administered. Data were analyzed using SPSS-26 and repeated-measures analysis of variance.
Results: The findings showed that in the post-test and follow-up stages, there was a significant difference between the experimental groups (emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy) and the control group (P < 0/001). The results also indicated that schema therapy was more effective than emotion-focused therapy in reducing feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in women.
Keywords: feelings of loneliness, emotional divorce, emotion-focused therapy, schema therapy, infertile women Introduction Infertility is a common problem worldwide, and up to 20% of couples are affected (Nguyen, 2014; Sadock & Sodock, 2007). According to reports from the World Health Organization, more than 80 million couples (about 10%) in the world are infertile. Meanwhile, based on different results, more than 3 million Iranian couples (13 to 15%) are infertile. The average lifetime prevalence of infertility in Iran is 10.9%, meaning 3.3% of the population experience common infertility. In the Middle East, infertility incidence is estimated at 10% to 15% (Nasr Esfahani et al., 2022).
According to the social role theory, a set of interdependent “rule-based and shaped expectations” is described as being resistant and stable, which provides the holder of particular social positions with value. In other words, the individual is directed toward a specific social position based on the expected role. Example: It is expected that a physician, according to the latest and most up-to-date level of medical research, will do everything possible to treat patients; or it is expected that a married woman will give birth to a child (or children) and will devote all efforts to raising them. In such cases, if the woman is infertile and does not meet the expectations that others in society have of her, she is essentially not fulfilling her social role properly (Afshari et al., 2019).
The social view of infertility states that common values and norms in society have a significant impact on the experience of infertility and on couples. In most cultures, having a child is considered a social value. Explicit and implicit norms indicate that couples want and should have children; therefore, when couples cannot have children, existing norms are disrupted and they may face social stigma. Family members and peers may hold negative views of the couple. Infertile people may offer difficult experiences when facing children and pregnant women; therefore, they may distance themselves from friends, experience social isolation, and may not participate in family gatherings in order to avoid feelings of failure (Loftus & Namaste, 2011; Rajabi et al., 2018).
Social isolation of women—limited interaction with friends, acquaintances, or neighbors—lack of access to support systems, and the presence of imposed psychological pressures, exposes them to greater strain in marital life and lowers their satisfaction with married life. In fact, the feeling of loneliness, especially if accompanied by adverse experiences of childhood abuse, leads to a reduction in perceived emotional and social support among women (Saeidi et al., 2020).
Feelings of loneliness are considered a psychological construct independent of other problems and can also involve other harms (Cava et al., 2021). Loneliness is not merely an objective lack of external companionship; rather, it refers to inner loneliness (Sandra et al., 2022).
An overall assessment of the marital relationship and the extent to which personal and couples’ needs, desires, and wishes are met determines the level of satisfaction or dissatisfaction with the marital relationship. One of the most important social harms is divorce. On the other hand, the roots of many social harms must, in some way, be considered in close relationship with the incorrect functioning of the family institution (Khan Mohamammadi et al., 2018). Often, after some time, a woman, a man, or both begin to doubt the depth and form of their relationship and fail to align their expectations about life with the realities of their marital life. As a result, they become cold and lose enthusiasm in their lives. Additionally, couples find that their spouse’s behavior is not what they expected. After this sense of disappointment emerges, they compare their spouse before and after marriage, and negative feelings overcome them, leading to the loss of initial enthusiasm, diminished emotional attachment, and ultimately the emergence of emotional divorce (Rezvani & Saemi, 2019). Specifically, infertility exacerbates emotional needs, affects one’s perception of the situation, creates negative emotions, intensifies a cold relationship, and leads to emotional divorce.
The experience of infertility goes beyond a physiological deficiency. Infertility also has psychological and social dimensions, causing both sexes to face a wide range of psychological harms, including reduced quality of life, lowered self-esteem, sexual dysfunction, marital problems, increased tension, feelings of loneliness, depression, emotional divorce, and feelings of inadequacy, along with many other issues. Infertility causes disturbances in sexual and emotional relationships, fear of separation, feelings of loneliness, and depression in infertile individuals; however, these problems affect women in society more. Infertility is a problem that is almost solvable in today’s world. Nevertheless, infertile women face psychological problems while waiting for this condition to be resolved (Nguyen, 2014).
Despite all medical advances, a significant proportion of infertile women and men remain among those who still have not succeeded in treating their infertility problem. Infertility is not only a medical condition; this issue and its treatment can affect various aspects of individuals’ lives and may bring along psychological and emotional problems such as depression, anxiety, hopelessness, feelings of guilt, and feelings of worthlessness (Afshari et al., 2019).
Regardless of which member of the couple is the main cause of infertility, due to social prejudice, infertility is considered a “female problem.” Therefore, women usually face more family and social issues than men and are exposed to more psychological harms. If early maladaptive schemas, as well as primary and secondary emotional processes and unmet emotional needs of infertile women are not resolved and do not lead to positive solutions, it can turn into tension in life. This is because early maladaptive schemas are self-harming emotional and cognitive patterns that form at the beginning of development and repeatedly occur throughout life (Young et al., 2006).
It is stated that emotion-focused therapy, using techniques from other approaches such as structured couple therapy approaches (attachment, adaptation, tracking the cycle, reappraisal), (client-centered) therapeutic alliance, self-disclosure, unconditional positive acceptance, empathy and mutual understanding (Gestalt therapy, problem-solving), strengthening relational strengths, highlighting individual capabilities and competencies, and also systemic approaches and attachment theory, helps improve couples’ relationships. Most of the time, purely logical and rational assessment (cognitive therapy) prevents the therapist from examining the emotional issues of the spouses. On the other hand, many couples’ problems originate from how they express underlying emotions. Emotion-focused therapy emphasizes identifying communication patterns, emotions, feelings, and the exchange of attachment styles. When individuals express their needs and desires to their spouse, they feel closer and more intimate, the relational turmoil decreases, and this leads to reduced feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce (Ahmadloo & Zeinali, 2018).
Additionally, the more individuals have greater numbers of early maladaptive schemas, the more these schemas cause bias in interpreting events, leading to misunderstanding, cognitive distortions, incorrect guesses and inferences, and unrealistic expectations in interpersonal psychological impairment. Schemas that lead to psychological problems can be described as being related to individuals’ intimate relationships and also to emotional divorce. The goal is to correct irrational ideas, inefficient beliefs, erroneous interpretations and cognitive errors; create a sense of control over life; facilitate constructive self-talk; and strengthen coping skills (Ussher & Perz, 2017).
Considering that research on psychological and family issues, including feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertility, is limited and a gap in research in this area is evident, and with the aim of examining psychological injuries in infertile women, the following hypotheses were pursued:
- There is a significant difference between the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness in infertile women.
- There is a significant difference between the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on emotional divorce in infertile women. Method, Statistical Population, and Sampling Method This research is an applied study conducted in a quasi-experimental design with a pre-test—post-test plan with a control group. First, pre-tests were administered to each of the three groups (two experimental and one control). The statistical population consisted of all infertile women who had referred to the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad in winter 1400, and the research sample was selected from among 45 women. Using convenience sampling, two experimental groups and one control group were randomly assigned. After attrition in the experimental groups, all groups were reduced to 12 participants each.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria: Inclusion criteria included having at least a high-school diploma, being married, diagnosis of primary and secondary infertility based on medical data, and not using psychotropic medications. Exclusion criteria included lack of willingness to cooperate and separation from the spouse during the period of conducting the sessions.
Before implementing the program, in order to apply maximum control, attempts were made so that the groups under study were, as far as possible, similar in terms of demographic characteristics (education, duration of marriage, and occupation). After the proposal was approved and the university council confirmed it by obtaining permission from the university and visiting the Milad Infertility Center in Mashhad, experimental and control groups were selected. Interventions for the experimental groups were held as two 90-minute sessions per week. Based on the protocol for emotion-focused therapy derived from the article by Seyed Sharifi and colleagues (Seyed Sharifi et al., 2021) and related books, as well as the protocol for schema therapy by Young (Young et al., 2006), the sessions were implemented by the researcher in year (1400). It should be noted that the control group received no intervention.
To observe ethical considerations, all participants were assured that their personal information would remain confidential. It should also be noted that this research was derived from the Ph.D. thesis in Counseling at Islamic Azad University of Mashhad and has the ethics code IR.IAU.MSHD.REC.1401.158, approved by and reviewed at the Faculty of Medicine of Islamic Azad University—Mashhad Medical Sciences Unit. Research Instruments 1. Loneliness Questionnaire This scale was developed by Russell and colleagues (Russell et al., 1980) in 1980. It includes 20 items, rated on a 4-point scale: 10 negatively worded sentences and 10 positively worded sentences. Scoring and interpretation in this questionnaire include: never (1), rarely (2), sometimes (3), and always (4). However, items 1, 5, 6, 9, 10, 15, 16, 19, and 20 are reverse-scored. That means they are coded as: never (4), rarely (3), sometimes (2), and always (1). The score range is between 20 (minimum) and 80 (maximum).
Therefore, the mean score is 50. Scores higher than the mean indicate greater intensity of loneliness. Validity and Reliability: Reliability of this test in its new revised version was reported as 78%. Test reliability using the test-retest method was reported by Russell and colleagues (Russell et al., 1980) as 89%.
This scale was translated by Shakarkan and Miredrikvand and was then used after preliminary administration and revisions (Naderi & Haqshenas, 2009). The validity of the questionnaire was assessed and approved as “good” using the opinions of supervising and consulting professors. 2. Gottman’s Emotional Divorce Questionnaire This scale, provided by John Gottman in the book Success or Failure in Marriage, consists of 24 items scored as yes (1) and no (0), measuring the level of emotional divorce (Gottman et al., 1998). Its validity and reliability have been applied based on the research by Rajai (Kimiaei et al., 2015). Further Findings Table 8 shows that the within-group repetition factor (F = 109/391, P = 0/001), the group-by-repetition interaction factor (F = 24/110, P = 0/001), and also the between-group factor (F = 70/990, P = 0/001) have a significant effect on emotional divorce in infertile women. The Bonferroni post hoc test showed that in the pre-test stage, there were no significant differences between the study groups (emotion-focused therapy, schema therapy, and control) in the variable of emotional divorce. However, in the post-test and follow-up stages, significant differences were observed between the emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy groups compared with the control group (P = 0/001).
Table 9: Results of repeated-measures ANOVA of the effect of schema therapy and emotion-focused therapy on the emotional divorce variable in infertile women Source of variation | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F value | Sig. | Effect Size Pre-test factor | 8/665 | 1 | 8/665 | 0/700 | 0/412 | 0/032 Group membership factor | 1270/515 | 1 | 1270/515 | 102/651 | 0/0001 | 0/63 Pre-test factor | 69/409 | 1 | 69/409 | 8/353 | 0/009 | 0/29 Group membership factor | 984/549 | 1 | 984/549 | 118/479 | 0/0001 | 0/55 In the comparison between emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy, the results showed that clinically, the effectiveness and effect size of schema therapy (Eta = %63) for the variable of emotional divorce is better and greater than that of emotion-focused therapy (Eta = %55). Discussion and Conclusion The aim of this study was to compare the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy on feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women, and the findings showed that the study is consistent with the results of Suleimanabadi and Suleimanabadi (Suleimanabadi, 2021). Infertility, as a factor, causes both sexes to experience a broad range of psychological harms including reduced quality of life, decreased self-esteem, sexual dysfunction and marital problems, increased tension, feelings of loneliness, depression, emotional divorce, and feelings of inefficacy.
Both emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy are effective in reducing feelings of loneliness in infertile women.
This finding is consistent with the results of Fatemi Asl and colleagues (Fatemi Asl et al., 2019). It is also consistent with Ghafari Shahir and colleagues (Ghafari Shahir et al., 2021) and PourMohamad G. and colleagues (PourMohamad G. et al., 2019). Nikoogoftar and Sangani (Nikoogoftar & Sangani, 2020) found in their study that group schema therapy is effective in reducing rumination, feelings of loneliness, and increasing general health among divorced women. Moradi et al. (2020) found that emotion-focused training reduces emotional divorce and coldness in women. The results of Esmaili et al. (2023) showed that schema therapy is effective in distress tolerance, emotional divorce, and marital intimacy in couples, which is consistent with the present study. This is also aligned with the studies by Enez (Enez, 2021), Greenman and Johnson (Greenman & Johnson, 2022), Thompson and Girz (Thompson & Girz, 2020), Sandra and colleagues (Sandra et al., 2022), and Bishop and colleagues (Bishop et al., 2022).
Reviewing the results showed that emotion-focused therapy can be effective in improving feelings of loneliness in infertile women. Regarding the effectiveness of emotion-focused therapy on loneliness in infertile couples, it is important to note that one of the primary goals of emotion-focused therapy is to change insecure attachment styles into secure attachment. Emotional contact emerges through availability and responsiveness. This bond and secure attachment meet the individual’s inner needs for safety, support, and connection. In secure marital relationships, if each person is confident that their spouse is available, that they have appropriate emotional support for one another, and that they value each other’s emotional needs, they experience less loneliness in their relationship (Bach et al., 2018).
In other words, a large part of the relationship among couples in Iranian society stems from emotional and psychological issues. Inability to express these emotions in a timely and appropriate manner initially leads to emotional withdrawal, the loss of intimacy, feelings of loneliness, and ultimately emotional divorce. In emotion-focused therapy, attention is given to identifying communication patterns, emotions, feelings, and the exchange of attachment styles among individuals. Communication and interaction patterns of spouses determine the level of trust and intimacy between couples, and destructive interaction style increases emotional distance, which in turn intensifies conflicting and negative emotions toward each other. Infertile women, who have unexpressed or suppressed emotions, do not receive the necessary and sufficient emotional support from their spouses and feel abandoned by their spouses. This results in distancing between the couple and feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce. Therefore, feelings of loneliness in infertile women are accompanied by all the psychological problems mentioned above, and using psychology approaches helps them improve considerably (Hoseinzade et al., 2021).
Regarding the effectiveness of the study results, schema therapy is more effective in improving feelings of loneliness and reducing emotional divorce. Considering that early schemas include people’s thoughts and beliefs about themselves, others, and the environment, created as a result of unmet early needs—especially emotional needs (Bach et al., 2018). Schemas and cognitive beliefs influence the course of marital relationships, and this issue has long been considered. When one or both spouses have high levels of irrational beliefs and inflexible thoughts, marital satisfaction gradually decreases (Hoseinzade et al., 2021).
Schema therapy helps infertile women talk about what is happening in their inner world as well as what they experience, including physical feelings, thoughts, beliefs, and values. When individuals gain insight into the origins of their maladaptive patterns, their life and relationship take on new meaning; they leave negative interactions and inappropriate personality patterns behind and move toward a healthier mindset. It also provides a way to escape life traps and meet their basic emotional needs. Schema therapy techniques help individuals, through emotional reorganization, examining new learning, interpersonal emotional regulation, and self-soothing, to create the conditions for improving schemas. These schemas generally operate at the deepest cognitive level, often outside conscious awareness. Schema therapy improves avoidant personality disorders, loneliness, and distancing behaviors (Titov et al., 2015).
With its multidimensional perspective and by considering the impact of cognitions and attitudes, schema therapy examines the roots of the problem in the past and seeks awareness and insight in women (Sedaghat & Afraee, 2022). The presence of maladaptive schemas is one of the main factors underlying the disruption of marital life. Some unfavorable and stressful environmental situations, such as infertility, activate maladaptive schemas that form within the individual and create the context for various forms of psychological distress, such as depression, feelings of loneliness, inefficacy, substance abuse, interpersonal conflicts, and personality disorders. Infertility reduces women’s social status and is accompanied by the activation of early maladaptive schemas and emotional disturbances; ultimately, it prepares the ground for forming a vicious cycle that intensifies infertility (Jahangiri et al., 2017). Also, maladaptive schemas have been identified as ineffective cognitive strategies that lead to dissatisfaction in marital relationships and create conditions for separation (AkgÜL GÖK et al., 2019; Mahmoudpour et al., 2020).
In both therapies, individuals learn to regulate their emotions and improve their relationship with themselves and their spouse by identifying and meeting their basic needs and by playing their determining roles. Schema therapy also helps women use healthier coping strategies for internal triggers. If the therapist presents mindsets to participants in a personalized manner, they will understand them better. The abandoned child is part of the person’s existence that, based on the theoretical assumptions of schema therapy, has been subjected to abuse, abandonment, emotional neglect, domination, and severe, cruel criticism by the early family.
In the present study, both emotion-focused therapy and schema therapy were effective in feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce in infertile women. The results showed that schema therapy worked better in reducing feelings of loneliness and emotional divorce. As a result, in addition to medical help for infertile women, schema therapy can be used to help infertile individuals. Regarding limitations, this study was conducted on infertile women; therefore, generalization to infertile couples or infertile men is not possible. It is suggested that the intervention be implemented with couples; and given the type of correlational research, it is also feasible with correlational designs.
At the end, the researchers would like to express their utmost gratitude and appreciation to all participants. In addition, there is no conflict of interest among the authors. References Afshari, P., Pejhan, A., & Rahmani Khalili, E. (2019). Factors and social consequences of infertility in shia and sunni women. Iran's Social Development Studies, 12(3), 103-115. https://jisds.srbiau.ac.ir/issue_2419_2470.html (In Persian)
Ahmadloo, M., & Zeinali, A. (2018). Predicting of emotional divorce based on novelty seeking, negative perfectionism and insecure attachment among employed women of urmia city. Iran Occupational Health, 15(2), 64-72. https://magiran.com/p1878272 (In Persian)
AkgÜL GÖK, F., Kapısız, S., Yilmaz, N., ÖZcan, S., & Duyan, V. (2019). Marital satisfaction and influencingfactors in infertile couples [İnfertil çiftlerde evlilik doyumu ve evlilik doyumunu etkileyen faktörler]. Cukurova Medical Journal, 44(3), 1074-1084. https://doi.org/10.17826/cumj.482385
Bach, B., Lockwood, G., & Young, J. E. (2018). A new look at the schema therapy model: Organization and role of early maladaptive schemas. Cognitive behaviour therapy, 47(4), 328-349. https://doi.org/10.1080/16506073.2017.1410566
Bishop, A., Younan, R., Low, J., & Pilkington, P. D. (2022). Early maladaptive schemas and depression in adulthood: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 29(1), 111-130. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2630
Cava, M.-J., Buelga, S., & Tomás, I. (2021). Peer victimization and dating violence victimization: The mediating role of loneliness, depressed mood, and life satisfaction. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 36(5-6), 2677-2702. https://doi.org/10.1177/0886260518760013
Enez, Ö. (2021). An overview of emotion-focused therapy. Current Research and Reviews in Psychology and Psychiatry, 1(1), 77-95. https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/crrpp/issue/68586/1075479
Esmaili, F., Zamordi, S., & Watankhah, H. (2023). The effectiveness of schema therapy on distress tolerance, emotional divorce and marital intimacy of couples. The tenth International Conference on Science and Technology of Educational Sciences, Social Studies and Psychology of Iran. https://civilica.com/doc/1966663.
Fatemi Asl, S., Goudarzi, M., Karimi Sani, P., & Boostanipour, A. (2019). The effect of emotionally-focused couple therapy (efct) on loneliness of hurt women from infidelity in salmas city. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology, 20(2), 48-57. https://doi.org/10.30486/jsrp.2019.665274 (In Persian)
Ghafari Shahir, M., Asadpour, E., & Zahrakar, K. (2021). Comparison effect of cognitive behavioral therapy and emotion-focused therapy on loneliness in married women victims of domestic violence [Research]. Advances in Cognitive Sciences, 23(1), 95-105. https://doi.org/10.30514/icss.23.1.95 (In Persian)
Gottman, J. M., Coan, J., Carrere, S., & Swanson, C. (1998). Predicting marital happiness and stability from newlywed interactions. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 5-22. https://doi.org/10.2307/353438
Greenman, P. S., & Johnson, S. M. (2022). Emotionally focused therapy: Attachment, connection, and health. Current Opinion in Psychology, 43, 146-150. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2021.06.015
Hoseinzade, Z., Ghorbanshirodi, S., Khalatbari, J., & Rahmani, M. (2021). The comparison of the effectiveness of emotionally focused couples therapy and reality therapy for couples on marital communication beliefs and marital expectations of couples [Original Research]. Journal of Assessment and Research in Applied Counseling, 3(2), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.52547/jarcp.3.2.1 (In Persian)
Jahangiri, M. M., Teimouri, H., & Tahmasebian, H. (2017). Effectiveness of schema therapy on reducing anxiety and depression in infertile women of arak city [Research]. Journal of Medical Council of Islamic Republic of Iran, 35(3), 259-263. http://jmciri.ir/article-1-2785-fa.html (In Persian)
Khan Mohamammadi, Z., Bazzazian, S., Amiri Majd, M., & Ghamari, M. (2018). Predicting emotional divorce based on psychological basic needs, marital expectations and family function. Journal of Family Psychology, 5(1), 17-30. https://doi.org/10.22034/ijfp.2018.245536 (In Persian)
Kimiaei, A., Mashhadhi, A., & Rajaei, A. (2015). Investigating the effectiveness of Gutman method couple therapy on reducing emotional divorce, improving verbal-non-verbal relationships and interpersonal cognitive distortions of conflicted couples. Ferdowsi University of Mashhad. Mashhad. https://ganj.irandoc.ac.ir//#/articles/fd40e43d1b42ddc3d95556222dfc6402
Loftus, J., & Namaste, P. (2011). Expectant mothers: Women’s infertility and the potential identity of biological motherhood. Qualitative Sociology Review, 7, 36-54. https://doi.org/10.18778/1733-8077.07.1.02
Mahmoudpour, A., Darba, M., Kamandloo, Z., & Madani, Y. (2020). The relationship between early maladaptive schemas with marital satisfaction and psychological distress in infertile women in tehran [Research]. Journal of Psychological Science, 19(94), 1231-1242. http://psychologicalscience.ir/article-1-771-fa.html (In Persian)
Moradi, A., Tabrizi, M., Karami, A., & Balanchi, N. A. (2020). The effectiveness of emotion-based education on emotional divorce and cold-tempered women in isfahan with an islamic approach. https://sid.ir/paper/415123/en (In Persian)
Naderi, F., & Haqshenas, F. (2009). The relationship between impulsivity and loneliness with the amount of mobile phone use in students. Findings in Psychology (Social Psychology), 4(12), 111-121. https://sid.ir/paper/175115/fa (In Persian)
Nasr Esfahani, M., Kalantar, S. M., Montazri, F., Rajabi, M., & Daneshmand, F. (2022). Aneuploidy assessment of x, y, 18 chromosomes in sperm of oligoteratospermia using fish technique [Original article]. The Journal of Shahid Sadoughi University of Medical Sciences, 29(11), 4312-4321. https://doi.org/10.18502/ssu.v29i11.8507 (In Persian)
Nguyen, K. (2014). Why unexplained infertility is sometimes explained during ivf. Resolve for the Journey and Beyond.
Nikoogoftar, M., & Sangani, A. (2020). The effectiveness of schema therapy on rumination, loneliness and general health of divorced women. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology, 21(2), 1-12. https://www.sid.ir/paper/375104/fa (In Persian)
PourMohamad G., K., Zare, M. R., & Mandanizade Safi, S. (2019). The effectiveness of emotionally focused couple therapy (eft) on improving marital satisfaction and reduction tendency to extramarital relationships women affected by domestic violence [Research]. Rooyesh-e-Ravanshenasi Journal (RRJ), 8(8), 221-230. http://frooyesh.ir/article-1-1442-fa.html (In Persian)
Rajabi, G., Karimi, M., & Amanelahi, A. (2018). Marital satisfaction, and coping strategies in fertile and infertile women of ahvaz. Biannual Journal of Applied Counseling, 8(1), 45-62. https://doi.org/10.22055/jac.2018.24978.1570 (In Persian)
Rezvani, H., & Saemi, H. (2019). Correlation between self-differentiation and neuroticism with emotional divorce in married students of azad shahr azad university [Research]. Journal of Health Promotion Management, 8(2), 23-30. http://jhpm.ir/article-1-912-fa.html (In Persian)
Russell, D., Peplau, L. A., & Cutrona, C. E. (1980). The revised UCLA loneliness scale: Concurrent and discriminant validity evidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(3), 472-480. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.39.3.472
Sadock, B. J., & Sodock, V. A. (2007). Synopsis & Psychiatry Behavioral Sciences/Clinical Psychiatry (Tenth Edition ed.). Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Philadelphia. https://www.amazon.com/Kaplan-Sadocks-Synopsis-Psychiatry-Behavioral/dp/1609139712
Saeidi, M., Khalatbari, J., Ghorbanshiroudi, S., & Abolghasemi, S. (2020). Comparison of the effect of cognitive-behavioral therapy with compassion-focused therapy on impulsivity of women on the verge of divorce. Community Health Journal, 14(1), 73-83. https://doi.org/10.22123/chj.2020.187285.1296 (In Persian)
Sandra, L., Koesma, R. E., Soetikno, N., & Dewi, F. I. R. (2022). Emotion-focused coping as a mediator in the relationship between loneliness and self-injurious behavior in adolescents during the covid-19 pandemic. Journal of Positive Psychology and Wellbeing, 6(1), 2526-2537. https://mail.journalppw.com/index.php/jppw/article/view/3222
Sedaghat, M., & Afraee, R. (2022). The effectiveness of schema therapy on reducing emotional divorce in women with military spouses. Military Psychology, 13(49), 147-164. https://www.sid.ir/fileserver/jf/690-264537-fa-1071728.pdf (In Persian)
Seyed Sharifi, M., Navabinejad, P. D., S., & Farzad, P. D., V. (2021). A comparison of the effectiveness of emotionally focused and schema therapies in reducing externalizing problems of children in female-headed households [Research]. Quarterly Journal of Family and Research, 18(2), 73-88. http://qjfr.ir/article-1-1912-en.html (In Persian)
Suleimanabadi, S. S., F. (2021). Psychological injuries in infertile women. The Fifth Conference of New Findings in Obstetrics, Gynecology, Childbirth and Infertility in Georgia - Tbilisi (November-2021), International Academy of Sciences and Studies of Georgia. https://civilica.com/doc/1319094 (In Persian)
Thompson, S., & Girz, L. (2020). Overcoming shame and aloneness: Emotion-focused group therapy for self-criticism. Person-Centered & Experiential Psychotherapies, 19(1), 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1080/14779757.2019.1618370
Titov, N., Dear, B. F., Ali, S., Zou, J. B., Lorian, C. N., Johnston, L., Terides, M. D., Kayrouz, R., Klein, B., & Gandy, M. (2015). Clinical and cost-effectiveness of therapist-guided internet-delivered cognitive behavior therapy for older adults with symptoms of depression: A randomized controlled trial. Behavior Therapy, 46(2), 193-205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2014.09.008
Ussher, J., & Perz, J. (2017). Evaluation of the relative efficacy of a couple cognitive-behaviour therapy (cbt) for premenstrual disorders (pmds), in comparison to one-to-one cbt and a wait list control: A randomized controlled trial. 12(4). https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0175068
Young, J. E., Klosko, J. S., & Weishaar, M. E. (2006). Schema therapy: A practitioner’s guide. https://www.guilford.com/books/Schema-Therapy/Young-Klosko-Weishaar/9781593853723